Take Note

An exploration of note-taking in Harvard University Collections

Notes and Philosophy

Greg Afinogenov

Just as Thomas Carlyle’s Sartor Resartus gets going in earnest, the fictional editor publishing the book’s centerpiece—a fictional treatise on the “philosophy of clothes” by the equally fictional German philosopher “Teufelsdröckh”—receives a package from his correspondent in Germany. Inside are

Six considerable PAPER-BAGS, carefully sealed, and marked successively, in gilt China-ink, with the symbols of the Six southern Zodiacal Signs, beginning at Libra; in the inside of which sealed Bags lie miscellaneous masses of Sheets, and oftener Shreds and Snips, written in Professor Teufelsdröckh's scarce legible cursiv-schrift; and treating of all imaginable things under the Zodiac and above it, but of his own personal history only at rare intervals, and then in the most enigmatic manner. Whole fascicles there are, wherein the Professor, or, as he here, speaking in the third person, calls himself, "the Wanderer," is not once named. Then again, amidst what seems to be a Metaphysico-theological Disquisition, "Detached Thoughts on the Steam-engine," or, "The continued Possibility of Prophecy," we shall meet with some quite private, not unimportant Biographical fact. On certain sheets stand Dreams, authentic or not, while the circumjacent waking Actions are omitted. Anecdotes, oftenest without date of place or time, fly loosely on separate slips, like Sibylline leaves. Interspersed also are long purely Autobiographical delineations; yet without connection, without recognizable coherence; so unimportant, so superfluously minute, they almost remind us of "P.P. Clerk of this Parish." Thus does famine of intelligence alternate with waste. Selection, order, appears to be unknown to the Professor … Only as a gaseous-chaotic Appendix to that aqueous-chaotic Volume can the contents of the Six Bags hover round us, and portions thereof be incorporated with our delineation of it.

The treatise and the note seem to be opposites of one another: where one is solid, unified, complete, the other is fragmentary and ephemeral, “unimportant,” “minute.” Yet Carlyle knew how indispensable notes were to his work. His marginalia on a book about Voltaire reveal not just the workaday underlining of a professional reader, but a distinctly personal voice: “Oh dear!”

Notes aren’t just an appendix: in their very evanescence, they can give us direct access to a whole mode of thinking. It was no accident that Vincent Placcius’s note closet, intended to prevent a chaos like Teufelsdröckh’s, was inspired by Francis Bacon’s collaborative vision of science; neither was it accidental that it ended up in the hands of Leibniz, who played a leading role in spreading scientific societies beyond London and Paris. It is not hard to imagine William James, doodling on his notes in medical school, asking himself if the factual truth of “reflex paraplegia” was really so pragmatically meaningful for his purposes.

Just as they reveal individual patterns of thought, notes can show us what happens when different ways of thinking collide. The pages of an annotated book bridge different times and places. The Scot Alexander Speirs, purchasing a copy of a German treatise, interleaved it with blank pages so he would have the freedom to muse on the philosophy of crime and punishment beyond the limits of its narrow margins. The Japanese intellectual Shinsuke Tsurumi, upon arriving at Harvard in the 1940s, dove headlong into the history of Western philosophy, especially the work of Kierkegaard, annotating his books in English as well as in Japanese.

At their most compelling, philosophical notes can constitute a whole century-long conversation on the meaning of a text or an idea. If the conversation in the pages of Rollo May’s pop-existentialist Man’s Search for Himself is simply an amusing aside, Walter Burley’s thirteenth-century commentary on Porphyry and Aristotle is a slow-motion debate about logic. The text itself, of course, is an interpretation of two major ancient writers. A fifteenth-century student, evidently in awe of the “most famous of doctors Burley,” carefully annotates the commentary. Finally, in the nineteenth century, the renowned semiotician Charles Peirce provides the book with a simple descriptive flyleaf that belies the thoroughgoing influence of scholastics like Burley on his own thinking. In one text, we move from classical to modern philosophy—a capsule history through the fractured medium of notes.

Keywords: 

Comments

Submitted by liuyu on

Monster beats outlet what happened Louis Vuitton Ireland within the coach tend to be more beautiful compared to the Louis Vuitton Canada Outlet television set. While i fill in the particular coach, adjacent to myself, the two girls, Louis Vuitton Outlet i use a sensitive make-up and still have some sort of louis Vuitton on her behalf get louis vuitton outlet , these guys any women using stunning gown, they could not really recognize one another. louis vuitton outlet online Persons Louis Vuitton Bags Online inside bus are performing their particular Louis Vuitton Outlet point, some slumbering, a few discussing, approximately studying, at one time Louis Vuitton Canada Sale , your ex with all the costume yell, oh, this a real lv luggage, the woman's raise your voice grab Sac longchamp pas cher the attention of the extremely tastes louis vuitton canada persons inside the bus, plus the Louis Vuitton Canada Handbags shop additional woman turn out to be extremely mortified, in addition to exhibited very soon, yet she Louis Vuitton Sale still hold the woman Louis Vuitton bags free shipping mood along with thought to girls if you wish Louis Vuitton Buy Handbags I'll assist you to rich person 1, I'm sure the online louis vuitton wall socket Louis Vuitton UK retailer.In today’utes Ghd Hair Straightener years, louis vuitton shoeshave come to be popular as well as Ghd Australia believed in lots of places around the globe. Originated from Italy, your Ugg Boots outlet architect “Louis Vuitton” ugg australia features a prominent baseborn of clients louis vuitton uk . Aside from shoes and boots, he or she companies some other products and to fill customer Gucci Bags Outlet demands along with basics just like Louis Vuitton totes. Louis Vuitton Outlet Inside full human race, Louis Vuitton has obtained louis vuitton outlet tremendous recognition in addition to popularity. Actually, thewomen louis vuitton shoes or boots are viewed Louis Vuitton Speedy 30 equally prominent Monster Headphones and extraordinary Monster Headphones By Dre

Submitted by liuyu on

Monster beats outlet so what happened Louis Vuitton Ireland within the tour bus will be more beautiful versus the Louis Vuitton Handbags Sale tv set. While i substitute the particular tour bus, close to myself, there's two young girls, Louis Vuitton Outlet i have a fragile makeup and also have A louis Vuitton on her behalf make louis vuitton outlet , another is some sort of females using lovely attire, they will often not acknowledge 1 another. louis vuitton outlet online Citizenry Louis Vuitton USA Online from the shuttle bus are going to do their Louis Vuitton Outlet factor, many sleeping, approximately speaking, many reading through, immediately Louis Vuitton Handbags Online , your ex with the costume cry, ohio, the item an actual fifty-five bags, your ex cry get Sac longchamp pas cher the eye of the very most tastes louis vuitton canada men and women inside coach, and the Louis Vuitton Canada wallet outlet additional young lady come to be really embarrassed, and also flashed quickly, but the girl Louis Vuitton Sale however keep the woman's Louis Vuitton uk sale mood in addition to believed to the girls if you would like Louis Vuitton UK Handbags Let me allow you to get one, I realize a good on line louis vuitton wall plug Louis Vuitton UK retailer.Throughout now’S Ghd Hair Straightener age, louis vuitton shoeshave grow to be recognized and Ghd Australia reckoned in lots of nations around the world of the world. Based upon Italy, the actual Ugg Boots outlet custom made “Louis Vuitton” ugg australia includes a huge base associated with patronage louis vuitton uk . Aside from place, he / she manufactures various other solutions and then to fill customer Gucci Bags Outlet requires in addition to needs like Louis Vuitton luggage. Louis Vuitton Outlet Inside solid globe, Louis Vuitton provides received louis vuitton outlet immense recognition in addition to reputation. In point of fact, thewomen louis vuitton footwear are considered Louis Vuitton Speedy 30 because exceptional Monster Headphones in addition to extraordinary Monster Beats cheap

Submitted by liuyu on

and even in times past, coach outlet that you just virtually apparent help to help examine all of it. Named among the biggest pictures of them moncler all, you'll find it maintains the actual differentiation to be the earliest 3rd party piumini moncler picture to help you get above $100 thousand around the system moncler business. Earlier piumini moncler mentioned that will, plenty ugg scarpe of merchants and even critics ugg scarpe contain described Hogan scarpe as it all ugg scarpe some of the most important show of your louis vuitton outlet 90's. Hogan scarpe The best piumini moncler reasons for Round moncler towards the Travel, a fairly entertaining different actioner through variety seasoned Walt Hillside, is usually Sylvester Stallone's encounter. Nullified in addition to beatup wanting, his / her tootanned body, creviced and also canyoned, has been be more responsive to the particular ravages associated with a sandblaster along with the pallor Hogan scarpe contains piumini moncler a waxy structure similar to certainly one of Madame Tussauds' brands. Anytime Underhanded is considered after moncler to produce a film's onelinerheavy conversation inside an individual's brand pike ugg sito ufficiale monotone, it truly is similar

Submitted by coachbag on

Early autumn season,Polo Ralph Lauren Outlet, should attend a friend,Michael Kors Outlet USA, about to go to sunshine literary pen,Coach Factory, say sunshine,Gucci Shoes UK, I have not been less,Coach Factory Outlet Online, it is indeed a beautiful scenery,North Clearance Outlet, fresh air,http://www.laurenpoloralph.com/, pleasant good place,Monster Beats Outlet Online, so after receiving the notice,Gucci Store Outlet, said nothing agreed,Polo Outlet Store Online, prior to departure,Coach Outlet Outlet, some gloomy weather,Ugg Boots Outlet, perhaps some get up earlier,Coach Purses On Sale, though it is fresh air,Gucci Shoes Outlet, but how much a bit chilly,Michael Kors Outlet, people feel the pace,Michael Kors Outlet Online, of the fall is near, car one way,http://www.gucci-shoesfactory.com/, there are a few raindrops,Coach Outlet Online, fall on the window,North Face Outlet Online, as if to tell us,MCM Backpack Outlet, that this trip sunshine, may be a very charm of the rain line.